Welcome to Charleston Real Estate Blog Sign in | Help

Foreclosure, statistics vs reality

I don't think a day goes by when I don't get an inquiry from someone wanting to buy a foreclosure in the Charleston real estate market. Let's forget about short sales, as I've said before, the seller can list the property and even accept a contract subject to bank(s) approval (even though you're unlikely to even get a response) but in the case of a foreclosure, the bank is the seller and you can write a contract and expect a successful closing (although you should expect the condition to be horrible at best).

The other day, the media headlines were typically negative regarding housing market conditions. When the foreclosure statistics are released, look for even more frightening headlines. But the reality is that 2 million foreclosures are only 4% of all the mortgages in the United States and only 2.6% of all homes in the country. Sure, that is too many but the headlines might have you think that since foreclosure activity surged by 90% year over year, that 90% of all homes were at some stage in the foreclosure process.

At year end, South Carolina had a 2.2% foreclosure rate and was ranked 39th in foreclosure activity. There are foreclosures of Charleston homes available to purchase (there are one or two in my neighborhood) but the Charleston real estate market is not as distressed as California, Florida, Nevada and some of the Midwestern states. It's important to read beyond the headlines.   

Jonathan Miller, writing at Matrix addresses the the perception that almost every home is in foreclosure and puts the statistics into context.

"We see huge percentage increases every single month and yet the typical reader doesn’t really know what these stats mean in the context of all mortgages outstanding other than…it’s getting worse. I don’t think I am alone in getting the feeling that 87.4% of all houses are under foreclosure (left-handed people only, while it’s 92.3% if you include right-handed people)."

Please read Jonathan Miller, [OTS] Foreclosures: From Malaise to Disarray

Despite these facts, I do expect a government bailout paid for by the taxpayers who continue to pay their mortgages on time to rescue those who did not. Remember, it is an election year.

Published Thursday, March 27, 2008 7:05 AM by Howard Arnoff

Comments

# re: Foreclosure, statistics vs reality

My guess is that we will start to see an a sharp increase in shorts sales and foreclosures by the end of summer...not from everyday home owners but from small builders.  I know several and they are running out of time an options.  They are leveraging one house to pay for another (and in some cases trying to build new houses so they can get a line of credit that they plan to use to pay for the other non sold homes).

Over the past two weeks I've seen more and more new construction homes being deeply discounted (as compared to where they were) and the seller is offering the house "as is" with plenty of finish work still to be done.    

Thursday, March 27, 2008 7:28 PM by Claude Daigle

# re: Foreclosure, statistics vs reality

Claude, I would have thought your next comments would have been on the stubborn sellers post.

As it happens, I had lunch at Rivertowne CC yesterday, a beautiful day to sit on the screened porch and enjoy a great cheeseburger and fries while overlooking the course and the marsh. When driving out, of course I noticed all those homes in the Planters Point subsection just at the entrance which in my (not so) humble opinion are on just about the worst lots in Rivertowne.

So this morning to respond to your comment, I looked up the activity and saw total price adjustments of 50, 38, -, 40, -, 40, 20, -, 50, 50, 50, 50, 50, 10, 30, -, -, -, 30 from original list prices. Most of the homes are in the 600's so it doesn't appear to be desperate price cutting there and by the way, I wouldn't buy one of them, as I said, the lots are not attractive.

As to builders (and these homes may not be from the builders you are referring to who are in financial hot water), they've been doing this since the beginning of time, generally they are builders, not business people and they always seem to get in financial trouble, close the company and start a new one.  

Friday, March 28, 2008 5:35 AM by Howard Arnoff
New Comments to this post are disabled